On September 23, the Munich Regional Court ruled that Micron infringed two YMTC German utility model patents and issued an injunction barring Micron from selling the infringing products in Germany. The case began in November 2023, and this is YMTC’s first substantive injunction in its global patent battle.
The ruling covers two German utility models: DE202020006166U1 (three-dimensional memory device step structure, case 7 O 12615/25) and DE202021004551U1 (barrier layer for word line contacts in 3D NAND, case 7 O 12614/25). The Munich court also heard three other YMTC cases against Micron involving DE202018007011U1, DE202022003278U1, and EP3931868, but postponed substantive rulings.

Micron rejected the decision, filed an appeal, and is challenging the patents’ validity through other proceedings. Micron noted that German utility models are registered by the German Patent Office without substantive examination and last up to 10 years. Legal analysts say enforcement depends on whether the Munich Higher Regional Court suspends the injunction during appeal. If not, YMTC can move quickly to enforce.
The 3D NAND patent dispute has lasted nearly three years. YMTC first sued Micron in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California in November 2023, later expanding to the Eastern District of Texas, the UK High Court, the Unified Patent Court, and the Munich Regional Court. Micron has fought back, asking the U.S. Patent Trial and Appeal Board to invalidate YMTC patents and filing a trade secret counterclaim against YMTC in the U.S. District Court for Idaho on September 16, 2026.
ICgoodFind: YMTC has scored win in Germany, while the global patent battle among memory makers heats up and 3D NAND IP competition intensifies.
